As I was rereading the tech page I realized that I didn't have to pull the new one out anyways. I was installing the new seal I did it opposite from the tech page (it says push the bottom in and work your way to the top, and I push the top in and tried working my way to the bottom) it wasn't working for me and I thought I should take it out and try again. When I took it out I noticed I damaged it. If you look at the seal from the back its got the swirls in the inner part of the ring and then theres this tiny lip, its the lip thats got the nick in it. Anyways Im getting a new one. Thanks